Poker News

Inside Gaming: Mel Gibson Wears Poker Goo; Former BetOnSports Exec Carruthers Sentenced

With poker at the center of our universe here at PokerNews, it's often easy to overlook everything else going on in the gaming industry. Today we're bringing you some sticky information regarding Mel Gibson, and news on BetOnSports chief...

David Carruthers Gets 33 Months Jail Time in BetOnSports Case

In April, former BetOnSports CEO David Carruthers pled guilty to racketeering charges stemming from his operation of the popular online sports book. He faced up to 33 months in prison and a maximum sentence was handed down on Friday.

U.S. District Court Judge Carol E. Jackson sentenced Carruthers on Friday after he was indicted by a grand jury four years ago, according to an article that appeared in Business Week authored by Bloomberg. In court late last week, Carruthers expressed remorse for his actions: “I understand now that the business was operating outside the laws of the United States. I realize I made the biggest mistake of my life. I am sorry for the actions of BetOnSports and the trouble it caused.” The company purportedly raked in over $1 billion in 2004 alone, with Bloomberg noting that a whopping 98% of wagers came from customers in the United States.

Carruthers had been under house arrest in St. Louis since 2006, but found time to get out and stretch his legs as part of the St. Louis Marathon. BetOnSports had been traded in London on the city’s stock exchange and Bloomberg added that Judge Jackson fined BetOnSports $28.2 million. However, the firm owes creditors in the United Kingdom and would likely not be able to make good on the $28.2 million penalty. Attorney Jeffrey Demerath told the financial news outlet, “We won’t be able to pay the $28 million. We have an obligation under the laws of the United Kingdom to pay the creditors first.”

A bevy of guilty pleas were entered in the BetOnSports case. In August, the company’s founder, Gary Kaplan, pled guilty to violating RICO in a Missouri courtroom. Kaplan received more than four years behind bars for his role in the company as well as a $43 million fine, according to the AFP news service. Assistant U.S. Attorney Steven Holtshouser commented in a press release distributed by the U.S. Department of Justice, “The prosecution and conviction of Carruthers is significant to the government's efforts at enforcement of U.S. laws against offshore Internet and telephone sports wagering businesses, because Carruthers was both a foreign national and a top executive of BetOnSports.” Kaplan was arrested in 2007.

In June, Neil Scott Kaplan, Lori Kaplan-Multz, and Penelope Tucker all entered guilty pleas in front of Judge Jackson in the BetOnSports case. Each agreed to hand over money in Swiss bank accounts, but would not face any jail time. Scott Kaplan and Kaplan-Multz also received time in a halfway house. An article that appeared in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch explained why the trio received significantly lighter sentences than Kaplan and Carruthers: “Assistant U.S. Attorney Steve Holtshouser said the sentences reflect the minimal roles that Neil Kaplan and Kaplan-Multz played, their lack of decision-making power there, and their willingness to surrender their BetOnSports money.”

The USA-facing online poker site Bodog, founded by Calvin Ayre, continues to accept wagers on sporting events. The site is in the midst of the National Football League (NFL) playoffs, which kicked off over the weekend. Carruthers assumed the head role at BetOnSports in 2004 after joining the company in 2000. Both the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) participated in the investigation of the former CEO. Besides Holtshouser, Steven Muchnick and Special Assistant U.S. Attorney Charles Birmingham led the case on behalf of the United States Government.

On Capitol Hill, the Poker Players Alliance (PPA) is carrying the flag for explicitly legal online poker in the United States. Financial services industry compliance with the regulations of the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA) was delayed six months to June 1st. The delay came after a November decision by U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke. Congressman Barney Frank (D-MA) is championing the cause on the Hill with HR 2267, which establishes a full licensing and regulatory framework for internet gambling outfits to solicit U.S. customers. The measure is up to 63 co-sponsors on both sides of the aisle, but would not permit online sports betting.

Stay tuned to Poker News Daily for the latest from the BetOnSports case.

Inside Gaming: BetOnSports Fined $28M; Macau Gambling Revenue Trumps Las Vegas

With poker at the center of our universe here at PokerNews, it's often easy to overlook everything else going on in the gaming industry. If you're as interested in all things gaming and casino as we are, you'll enjoy the fruits of our research by...

Gary Kaplan Pleads Guilty in BetOnSports Case

Gary Kaplan, the founder of BetOnSports, has pled guilty to violations of RICO and the Wire Act in a Missouri courtroom. He will face between 41 and 51 months behind bars and pay the United States Government $43.65 million.

According to a press release distributed by the U.S. Department of Justice, Kaplan established businesses in Costa Rica, Antigua, and Aruba. One company was BetOnSports, which advertised heavily to U.S. customers and offered the following technological prowess: “Kaplan’s toll-free telephone lines terminated in Houston or Miami and then were forwarded to Costa Rica by satellite transmitter or fiber-optic cable. Some of Kaplan’s Web servers were located in Miami and were remotely controlled from Costa Rica.”

The Department of Justice contends that in 2004, BetOnSports had 1,700 employees in Costa Rica alone and nearly one million registered customers. Its clientele issued more than 10 million bets that combined for over $1 billion. Also in 2004, BetOnSports held an initial public offering (IPO) on the London Stock Exchange that earned Kaplan $100 million. He was arrested in March of 2007 and sentencing will take place on October 27th. He has been held without bond ever since being detained by U.S. authorities.

Former BetOnSports CEO David Carruthers pled guilty to racketeering charges in April and now faces up to 33 months behind bars. Carruthers, who was detained in St. Louis, will learn his fate during a sentencing hearing on October 2nd. In June, Neil Scott Kaplan, Lori Kaplan-Multz, and Penelope Tucker all pled guilty for their roles with BetOnSports. None will receive jail time, although Tucker was issued a one year probation. Kaplan’s trial had been scheduled for September 21st before last week’s plea agreement was announced.

Interactive Media Entertainment and Gaming Association (iMEGA) Chairman Joe Brennan, who has been closely monitoring the actions in the BetOnSports case, told Poker News Daily, “It sounds like Kaplan’s plea agreement is complex. However, his risk against going to jail for a long time seems to have been minimized. There may also be some recognition that he’s already spent a significant amount of time behind bars.” Last August, William Hernan Lenis, Will Lenis, and Manny Lenis became the first BetOnSports staffers to admit guilt. The trio advertised the online sports betting outfit; one stunt involved bringing an RV to a St. Louis Rams game in 2002, enabling fans to place bets before entering the stadium.

In June, the Southern District of New York (SDNY) seized over $30 million in payments destined for more than 24,000 online poker players in the United States, marking one of the first times that the industry has been the target of federal law enforcement actions. Brennan explained, “Under the new administration, there has been no softening of the stance by the Justice Department towards internet gambling. When you look at what happened with Kaplan and what’s happening with the SDNY, it may be discouraging to those who thought that with the new administration, there would be less hostility towards internet gambling.”

On Friday, attorneys for Account Services will appear in the Southern District of California calling for the return of $14 million seized by the SDNY in June. Recently, Douglas Rennick, an individual associated with the company, was indicted on bank fraud, money laundering, and illegal gambling charges. He faces up to 55 years in jail and $1.75 million in fines. Brennan forecasted, “I’m sure that during the course of Friday’s hearing, there is going to be some discussion that the Department of Justice may prefer to see the criminal matter resolved before any civil action can move forward.” The Poker Players Alliance (PPA) has submitted an amicus brief in the case outlining that poker is a game of skill and therefore not illegal gambling.

FBI Special Agent John Gillies noted that Kaplan’s guilty plea was monumental: “Today’s guilty plea should have a lasting effect because Kaplan was not only the founder of BetOnSports, he was also one of the pioneers of illegal online gambling.”

More Guilty Pleas in BetOnSports Case

Neil Scott Kaplan, Lori Kaplan-Multz, and Penelope Tucker have all pled guilty to U.S. District Court Judge Carol E. Jackson, according to an article published by Bloomberg on Tuesday. Now, BetOnSports Founder Gary Kaplan faces trial on September 21st.

Former BetOnSports Chief Executive Officer (CEO) David Carruthers pled guilty in April and faces up to 33 months behind bars. Carruthers’ sentencing is scheduled for October. A statement released by iGamingNews at the time noted that Carruthers planned to cooperate against others who were still being held by the U.S. Department of Justice. Now, only Kaplan remains. The other defendants pled guilty to “racketeering conspiracy and the illegal transmission of bets,” according to Bloomberg.

Kaplan was arrested in the Dominican Republic in March of 2007. An article published by BBC News two years ago noted that BetOnSports reaped 95% of its profits from U.S. residents and exited the market in August of 2006. That October, the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA) was signed into law by then-U.S. President George W. Bush. The measure prohibited the transfer of funds from banks and other financial institutions to illegal internet gambling outfits, although it failed to specify what activities were permissible. The regulations of the UIGEA were approved as “midnight rules” in November and implemented on January 19th, one day before President Barack Obama took office. The financial services industry must come into full compliance with the UIGEA by December 1st.

Carruthers was kept under house arrest in St. Louis after being picked up by U.S. authorities in Texas in 2006. According to Bloomberg, Kaplan faces charges of “racketeering conspiracy, mail fraud, and wire fraud.” His brother, Neil, told Judge Jackson, “Having seen my brother’s companies advertised openly on billboards in New York and other places, I believed his company was lawful.” His sister, Lori, pled guilty to “racketeering conspiracy and the illegal transmission of wagers,” according to the U.S. news outlet.

The St. Louis Post-Dispatch noted that Neil, Lori, and Tucker each will fork over money held in Swiss bank accounts as part of the agreement. The former two will spend time in a halfway house, but not be imprisoned for soliciting U.S. customers. Tucker will receive a one year probation and pay $15,000. The Post-Dispatch explained, “Assistant U.S. Attorney Steve Holtshouser said the sentences reflect the minimal roles that Neil Kaplan and Kaplan-Multz played, their lack of decision-making power there, and their willingness to surrender their BetOnSports money.”

Party Gaming entered into a non-prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York in April. As part of its agreement, the company agreed to pay a $105 million fine over a three and a half year period. In December, one of its co-founders, Anurag Dikshit, admitted to violating the Wire Act of 1961 in a New York courtroom. He faces up to three years behind bars and will be sentenced later this year. Dikshit is in the process of paying a $300 million fine. Forbes noted that Dikshit has a net worth of $1 billion and currently resides in Gibraltar. He developed the client software for Party Gaming, which owns and operates PartyPoker.

Also in the background of today’s developments is the seizing of over $30 million in online poker payment processor funds by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District, which is the main office charged with handling financial crimes. No legal action has yet been filed in the case. Poker Players Alliance Chairman Alfonse D’Amato, appearing on Fox Business, explained, “It is not illegal for a person to play poker on the internet. What the [UIGEA] did was say that the payment processors, the financial community, could not distribute these funds.”

No indication was given as to what Kaplan’s future now holds.

Carruthers Offers Guilty Plea in BetOnSports Racketeering Case

Former BetOnSports CEO David Carruthers pled guilty on Wednesday to US federal racketeering charges in the latest development in the ongoing prosecutions brought by the US Justice Department in its war against the now defunct...

BetOnSports Ex-CEO David Carruthers Pleads Guilty

In breaking news out of St. Louis, former BetOnSports CEO David Carruthers has pled guilty to “federal racketeering conspiracy charges,” according to the Associated Press. He faces up to 33 months in prison and sentencing is scheduled for October 2nd.

According to a statement released by iGamingNews on Wednesday, “Mr. Carruthers agreed to not appeal provided that the sentence doesn't exceed 33 months, which is under the terms of the agreement, as well as to not engage in offshore gambling businesses during the time of supervised released or thereafter.” Carruthers also agreed to cooperate against BetOnSports founder Gary Kaplan and others still in custody.

Carruthers has been under house arrest since 2006 and even ran the St. Louis Marathon during his detention, posting a time of four hours, five minutes, and 27 seconds. He was originally detained in Texas while in transit from the United Kingdom to Costa Rica before being moved to St. Louis. According to the St. Louis Post Dispatch newspaper, despite believing that internet gambling and sports wagering may have been illegal in the United States under laws such as the Wire Act of 1961 and Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA), Carruthers “continued to advertise to U.S. customers that the company was 'legal and licensed' while 'furtively or covertly' collecting bets and paying out money owed to gamblers.”

Interactive Media Entertainment and Gaming Association (iMEGA) Chairman Joe Brennan speculated as to why Carruthers would finally plead guilty, ending the three year ordeal. He told Poker News Daily, “Carruthers is a citizen of the United Kingdom and isn't a resident of the United States. He was a foreign national that had been detailed in transit. He went three years trying to make the best of a bad situation and wants to go home.”

In July of 2006, Carruthers was fired as CEO of BetOnSports. The company stated at the time, "Clearly, while he remains in the custody of the U.S. government, he is unable to perform his duties.” In August of that year, the company vacated the U.S. market entirely, two months prior to then-President George W. Bush signing the SAFE Port Act and its accompanying UIGEA rider into law. Brennan noted that while BetOnSports was navigating its future business plans, Carruthers was still held up in Missouri: “The U.S. Government won a war of attrition. He's an older guy who hasn't been home in three years. He was under house arrest with no trial.”

The admission of guilt comes on the heels of a plea bargain made by former Party Gaming Co-Founder Anurag Dikshit in a New York court room last December. Dikshit agreed to pay $300 million over three installments and faces up to two years in prison. However, his sentencing has been delayed until December of 2010. Comparing the two high profile internet gambling proceedings, Brennan explained, “Carruthers' case is obviously more severe than Anurag's, who is free to go wherever. It's disappointing to see a guy who has been standing on his principles beaten down enough to forge a plea.”

Visiting BetOnSports.com from the United States yields the text, “This website does not accept wagers on sports or sporting events from persons in the United States. It is a violation of United States Law to transmit sports wagers or betting information to this website from the United States.”

We'll have more for you on this breaking story has it develops right here on Poker News Daily.